Jump to content

tip for whip finishers

Rate this topic


tommycod

Recommended Posts

Here"™s a tip about modifying a recalcitrant whip finisher. Got this puppy when I saw a video and said "I"™ve got to get me one of these!".naughty.gif He wrapped that head like a spider doing an ant. Mine was the T type and not the Z type(Cabelas 314155 or Dr.Slick). No instructions came with it so I took it to my local fly club tying clinic, asked how to use it.cwm13.gif The old timers there looked at it and said 'Yeah, I've seen one before; don"™t know, don"™t use one; I use my fingers"™. However they couldn"™t show/figure out how to use it. I found a book with clear instructions, but they used the Z type which is supposed to be better. That still couldn"™t help me to use my T type with its strange bent-over crook at the tip top; just could not get it done! mad.gif I borrowed a Z type and had no problem! So I figured it was in the geometry of the tip- not me.redface.gif Can"™t use mine; nothing to loose if I broke it, so I bent the bent-over crook to be more like the Z type tip in configuration. Used gentle heat and needle pliers and it now my T finisher works great! Maybe even better than the Z type.icon14.gif I"™m sure the original bent crook works or why would they sell it--don"™t answer that.

 

ps. Much thanx to TimS for help with image posting; he does a great job.The Z is on the left and my modified T on the right; note reconfigured T's tip is similar in orientation to the Z with respect to lower arm.

 

whips3.JPG

Still chasin' tail
Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMHO... the best tip for whip finishers is to throw 'em out the window and learn to whip finish with yer fingers.

 

I hate those things. They were made by the devil, designed by his brother and never do anything for me but drive me to drinking.biggrin.gif

 

That said...

 

Good tips!

Ack. Foo.

I want to die from a good old fashioned case of living.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

need to WF? cwm13.gif it makes a great, secure head which i nail polish anyway; all that epoxy mixing is a PITA & i save that for really impt stuff. epoxy would do it if that's part of that fly. true that whipping w your fingers is convenient, but w smaller threads like 6/0 , i find that my fat fingers and rough fingertips make that a very dicey deal.frown.gif

IMHO the right equipment often makes a job easier and better; besides - it's another toy to play with.cwm12.gif

Still chasin' tail
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course you could just google "whip finisher instructions" and watch the video on *********. It's an elegant little tool just the way it is.

 

went to the site and sawpictorial from a search of WHIP; the secret that i missed was "With the open end of the s-shaped bend on the end of the whip finisher, hook the thread as it comes off the fly. Then lay the thread from the bobbin in the dip of the s-shaped bend nearest the arm of the whip finisher." cwm13.gif I still like the matarelli Z style better, but my bending made my thompson T type more of a Z. Al Campbell of FAOL says(You might see a simple whip finisher; it functions the same as the Matarelli.). I guess i turned my thompson into a simple style.

Would be interesting to try the T the way they recommend however. I had been to the site several times, but not realized that great resouce. thanxredface.gif

For those all naturals out there, chew on this; according to Al Campbell

"Whip finishers are probably the least used and least understood, basic tool in the average fly tyer"™s arsenal. This is the tool that creates the nice knot at the head of the fly that keeps the fly together. If your flies fall apart, it"™s most likely due to the whip knot you didn"™t do or didn"™t do right when you finished the fly.

Some fly tyers use their fingers to do a whip finish knot. Although this often provides an acceptable knot, it sometimes provides an un-acceptable knot. Since learning to use a whip finisher is one of the basic skills of fly tying, I"™ll show you how to use the tools right. I won"™t show you how to do a whip knot by hand, at least not until the series is over, and maybe not then. I"™m convinced that this is one skill you must learn to do right to be as good a tyer as possible." tongue.gif . I don't know Al personally, but he seems to really know his tying tools.

Still chasin' tail
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldn't take that quote literally. I assume it's hyperbole to rationalize his point.

 

Whip finishing, whether by tool or hand is not rocket science. It's an easily mastered skill for most tyers.

 

BTW, I use my fingers because it is much faster than a tool. Yet, I'm sure that one day I'll be back to using a tool when I become burdened by the afflictions of age.

Best regards,
Roger
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I actually knew Al quite well... he's gone now.

 

I don't know why, but I hate those whip finishers... and I've never had a knot fail me from whip finishing by hand. It's another of those beautiful things about flyfishing and fly tying... there's no one right way to do things.icon14.gif

 

Accourse I have tied ONE fly since my shoulder surgeries a few years ago... so there ya go. From thousands of flies a year to one fly in three years.... woohooo.

Ack. Foo.

I want to die from a good old fashioned case of living.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like my Matarelli.

It's fast and I never break thread with it.

I got the big one so I can do pretty large salt water flies, but I can also tie off a 26 midge.

 

I use one to...can't beat it, faster than fingers,very accurate, through all the others away!

"Nick did not like to fish with other men on the river. Unless they were of your party, they spoiled it." Ernest Hemmingway, "Big Two Hearted River (1925)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to register here in order to participate.

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×
×
  • Create New...