I liked the first episode albeit for some dangerous maneuvers by a few of the boat captains.
After watching shows 2 & 3, though, I think it might be better suited for MTV! It's like a soap opera. Would love it if there was some instruction. Something educational about it. E.g., it would've been nice to see the chef demonstrate how he removes the bass' bones, forming that incredible body cavity. Or if Paul showed which fly he was throwing to immitate the rain bait.
Watching "Matt" go off on some guy, talking about beating him up, etc., was really whacky. We don't need that on a fishing show, do we? Especially from a grown man (what, 45-50 ys old?).
Not sure if it's poor editing, but do the guides really chase blitzes and diving birds all day? Doesn't seem like there's a lot of skill involved in that. What about picking bass off structure when they're not showing?