Seely's Pond is stocked with trout and has some panfish and bass. It also has a lot of carp. It's not a great pond because it gets so warm in the summer and gets swampy. All the trout will go belly-up in June from the heat.
Surprise Lake is nice. Some big fish in there including bass, pickerel and channel cats. Also has panfish. Better get there before the lilly pads grow, because it'll become hard to fish when the lake is covered with them.
Surprise Lake also gets warm in the summer and the fish get really sluggish in the heat, so get there early in the morning.